MoBSE enjoys fruitful partnership with donors
Mr. Sheriff Yunus Hydara has been working with the Ministry of Basic and Secondary Education (MoBSE) since 1999, and has seen the biggest ministry in Government grow from strength to strength. In this interview with Adama Jimba Jobe, he talked about the experiences he has gathered during twelve years of working in MoBSE. As Project Manager, Project Co-coordinating Unit, he talks about donor funding and other relevant activities in his unit.
* Thank you for granting us this interview. I believe it will give our readers a better understanding of the roles and responsibilities of the Project Coordinating Unit, MoBSE. Can you start by telling us about yourself particularly your educational background?
First of all, let me thank you Mr. Jobe and Fatou Kinneh for this interview. To start with, let me introduce myself. I started my primary education at the Senegalese Primary School in Banjul, Tobacco Road. I later proceeded to Kaolack for my high school, where I obtained a baccalaureate in science, maths, physics and biology.
From there, I went to Malaysia to do my first degree in Economics and had a minor in Business Administration. Upon my return in 1998, I worked for a short time with the University Extension Programme first and then I later went to The Gambia Technical Training Institute (GTTI). After that I joined the Energy Division of the Ministry of Trade before moving to the World Food Program (WPF).
I think it was after the WFP that I came to work with the Ministry of Basic Secondary Education in 1999. In 2001, I went for my Master’s Degree in Economic Policy and Management at the United Nations Institute for Economic Development in Dakar. In brief, that is my educational background.
*As a Project Manager I understand you assist the Permanent-Secretary in managing project/donor funds for the sector. What are the other key functions of the Project Manager?
One of the key functions of the project manager, as you rightly said, is technically to advise the Permanent-Secretary in managing the resources of the development partners. We help in mobilizing resources for the sector and also in coordinating the activities of the various Directorates that implement the programs we execute within the context of the Policy and Strategic Plan.
The PCU is also the custodian of the resources of the sector. That is why the unit has a fiduciary function, fiduciary in the sense that we have a Financial Management Unit (FMU) and a Procurement Management Unit (PMU), where all the other activities that are implemented in relation to finance and procurement are handled.
We also advise the sector to adhere to rules and guidelines that regulate financial management and procurement as far as donor resources are concerned. Furthermore, we have a Donor Coordination Unit, which supports the development partners both in and outside the country in the activities they implement in the Education Sector.
We have a Construction Program Unit (CPU), which supervises the construction activities (in) of the ministry. We normally delegate this to the Directorate of Maintenance, Gamworks, or, through framework agreements, to NGO’s like Future In Our Hands and Child Fund as well as to contractors through competitive biddings.
That is why within the Construction Unit, we have the Construction Monitors located within the Regional Education Directorates to perform such duties. In a nutshell, our role is to advice management in terms of fiduciary functions, construction and donor coordination.
*From your explanation of the functions of your directorate, it seems you deal with many donors. Can you share with us the donors that have collaborated with the sector in the last 5 years’ and the status of such collaboration?
Our collaboration with donors has been very fruitful. The Education Sector has been quite lucky to attract a number of development partners. The strategy we take in the sector is the SWAP approach. In this approach, we take the lead and the development partners accompany us to realize the goals and objectives we set for ourselves.
In the past five years, we have had interventions from the African Development Bank (ADB), the United Kingdom’s Department For International Development (DFID), the Arab Bank for Economic Development (BADEA), the Islamic Development Bank as well as the World Bank through the IDA.
We have had access to resources through the Education For All / Fast Track Initiative Catalytic Fund, which is a pool of resources mainly from the Scandinavian countries. Furthermore, we have had access to many other trust funds like the EPDF at the level of the World Bank.
The EPDF is another trust fund managed by the EFA / FTI secretary and that allowed us to carry out activities such as the Youth Employment Study, the Country Status Report and the National Language.
*Mr. Hydara, in your presentation at one of the Coordination Committee Meetings (CCMs), you alluded to the fact that the Education Sector is becoming a donor orphan. Can you explain to our readership what you actually meant by that?
In my answer to your previous question, that is what I did not cover; and (That was why) I was hoping that the question would be raised. If you look at the sector at the moment, the intervention of ADB has phased out. The same applies to the UK/DFID intervention. I think the BADEA is also phasing out in 2011.
So right now, the only interventions, which we are left with, are the IDA III and the EFA - FTI and both of them are phasing out by December 2012. There is no guarantee that after that we will have additional resources. We are working to see if we can get support from our local partners, but we are also exploring other avenues for funds.
For a sector that had the intervention of more than five development partners over the past five years, being reduced to only one development partner is quite worrying. That is why I keep saying that if we were a donor orphan, we are more than ‘orphaned’ now.
*What would you say are the implications on the education sector as far as that is concerned?
The implications are serious. We all know that if you exclude personal emoluments from our salaries, the national budget covers barely less than 10% of the resources. We all know the amount of teaching and learning materials that are required in our schools.
If not the resources of the development partners, it would have been very difficult for the sector to construct classrooms, allocate furniture, teaching and learning materials, and the technical assistance we are giving to our staff in terms of capacity building both overseas and locally.
The development partners support all the above activities of MoBSE. So if we lose them, it may affect our programs. That is why it is important that we address the issue of donor funding. The sector is taking the bull by the horns by aggressively trying to mobilize more resources before the end of 2012.
*Sir, I also learnt that some time back, the Hon. Minister led a high powered delegation to the World Bank in Washington, USA. What was the objective of the visit? What was the outcome of the meetings or sessions you held with the Bank and other development partners, while you were in Washington?
I may need the whole day to answer these questions. This is because it was a 15-day meeting and as you have said, it was really a high powered meeting. Somehow, people thought it was by coincidence. But we timed it in such a way that the delegation could participate in the Spring Meetings at the World Bank for the sole purpose of ensuring that development partners’ are well aware of the situation in The Gambia, and to sensitize the authorities in the Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs (MoFEA) to the real state of affairs in the sector.
As a result, we made sure that we did not go there only with the Secondary and Basic Education staff, but we also mobilized the whole education sector from the basic to tertiary level as well as staff from MoFEA. We went with the two permanent secretaries of MoBSE and the Ministry of Higher Education Research Science and Technology in addition to the Honorable Minister of MoBSE.
The purpose of the visit was (of) two- fold. One was to carry out what we called the mid- term review of the EFA / FTI program to see how far we have gone. By the time we were going to Washington, we had already disbursed 51% of the resources that were allocated to us. The Gambia was the only country that was able to disburse 51% of the resources that were allocated for three years within a year. So that was a success.
But the visit also allowed us to look at the challenges that we are facing and how to address them in order to move our development plan forward. On one hand, we discussed challenges and the way forward. On the other hand, we looked at ways of accessing additional resources’ under the EFA / FTI.
The meetings we held in Washington gave us the opportunity to share experiences and discuss with technical experts at the level of the World Bank and other Institutions that are based in Washington.
We also had the opportunity to discuss at length the issues of the Higher Education National STI Policy that we have to develop. We had very successful discussions with the World Bank. We were able to share our visions with them.
In addition, we shared some of the pilot experiences that the bank is doing in other countries including ICT in education. We saw that the bank is really doing good work in countries like Nigeria.
During the mission, we had a chance to meet with the United States Agency for International Development. We realized that this was an institution that is very much into early grade reading. We have already started the discussion on how we can strengthen the collaboration and the partnership with them. We are hopeful that we can also tap resources from United States Agency for International Development.
The trip allowed us to showcase The Gambia’s education system. The Permanent Secretary made a presentation on the sector entitled “Road Towards Improving Teaching and Learning” at the Broud Back Lunch (BBL). The meeting was highly attended by senior officials of the bank and they were all very impressed with the presentation and the achievements of the basic education sector of The Gambia.
We used it as an opportunity to showcase the big problems we are facing, which are mainly about the lack of resources’ and the need to mobilize more resources to support the sector to maintain and sustain the gains we have registered over the years. We were also at the presentation of a book on ICT in Agriculture by a Kenyan professor.
The Honorable Minister also participated in the Spring Meetings and she took the opportunity to table the issues of the education sector in The Gambia before the WB’s senior officials most notably the vice-president and other representatives of other institutions like the Africa Development Bank. All of us who were present at the meeting agreed that there was a need to continue supporting the sector so as to sustain the gains accomplished over the years.
Prior to our visit, we were not going to be part of the International Development Agency’s 16 Funding. But the meeting made everybody to realize that you have to make education a priority. Both the Government delegation led by both Honourable Ministers from MoBSE and Finance and the donor community including World Bank officials’, the African Development Bank officials’ and the International Monetary Fund officials’ all realized that there is a need for the education sector to benefit from the envelop of the IDA16. That was one of the greatest achievements of our trip.
*The word Fast Track Initiative (FTI) has become a household name in The Gambia. Can you tell us something about the FTI and the role it plays in the Education Sector?
The Fast Track initiative was led by the donor community. The main purpose of initiating it was to assist countries such as ours, which are really faced with budget constraints and resource scarcity, in achieving the goals they set for themselves in terms of the Education For All (EFA). The Scandinavian countries are the main sponsors of EFA.
It is governed by a board that has well experienced educationists who review proposals from the applying countries. Those sectors with viable plans that are cost and well programmed will be voted for by the donor community. This is what the FTI is all about. But because people do not understand it, they just give it any connotation.
Luckily for us in The Gambia, the support being given to us by the FTI is really making a positive impact on our development. We hope we will continue to benefit from the FTI Funds.
*Mr. Hydara, I would like you to throw light on how projects are implemented, with a particular focus on disbursement?
This is something that may be very complex for the layman to understand. But it is not a difficult thing and it is not rocket science. Like I was saying, you know we normally implement our projects through the support of our development partners. We have our plans, which we present to them. They buy in into our plans, which are drawn from the policy and other sector programs.
If our plans are credible, the development partners and regional community will accept them. But we sell it and they buy into it. It is at that stage we do the planning and appraisal. This requires us to look at what we need and what the current issues are as well as the emerging ones that we need to address when the resources’ are scarce.
Through that we develop project appraisal documents. After appraising the documents, we present them to the board of governors of donor institutions including the World Bank, the FTI Board, and BADEA amongst others. Once it is approved at that level, we start negotiations to agree on the implementation strategy.
For example, how are we going to do the procurement? How are we going to do the disbursement? From there we sign what we call the financial agreement. Upon signing the financial agreement, we sometimes have effectiveness conditions. That is to say that as a government or a Ministry, we have to do ABC before we have access to the funds. It is at that stage that the disbursement starts.
Disbursement is connected to implementation because every other activity has to follow certain procedures and guidelines to be implemented. We have the obligation to report financially because in the past we used to be reporting through statements of expenditure. But now it is more of Intermediate Financial Report (IFR) statements that we send to the Bank to replenish our account.
Every three months, we need to send a statement and provide explanation on how we are utilizing the resources and the bank will review it, approve it and then forward it. With that we are entitled to replenishment, once, we utilized it up to a certain level, which is normally not beyond 25%.
So we have to ??? first disbursement that we request, but we have to first spend that amount, explain that amount back to the bank for them to review all those things. At the level of the World Bank, it is not the TTL in Washington that is in charge of this, but a special unit called the Disbursement Unit, which is based in India. All these things are electronically done at the level of the PCU.
We fill the form electronically, forward it to the MoFEA electronically. Then MoFEA does its part to the notes directly and then approves it, following which they sell it officially. This is because as a unit, we cannot request for disbursement. Consequently, we have what we call a withdrawal application, which we fill electronically now as opposed to the past when we had to do it through paper work. After filling it, we forward it electronically to MoFEA, who will read it, approve it and then the bill will be directly paid in the accounts. This makes our work very easy as both the procurement and the financial processes are done electronically.
*Is retirement an issue in the sector, particularly from implementing agencies? If so what advice do you have for those agencies and institutions?
When it comes to financial matters, this is an issue that we really need to look at closely because as custodians of the resources in the sector we have two mandates. Firstly, we have to ensure that resources are utilized following financial instructions.
Secondly, we have a mandate to ensure that the resources are utilized for the purposes they are meant for. This is where the issue of retirement comes in. These are public resources that we are custodian of, and that we are answerable for.
These are also accounts that are going to be audited at the end of the year. So if we disburse resources to an implementing unit or office, it is an obligation upon utilization of those resources to retire them accordingly with all the required original documents.
But we have definitely been having issues with the retirement of funds. So far some of them do delay submission, while others are poorly submitted.
Recently, we even conducted a training to share with the implementing bodies the frustrations that we sometimes face because these are bulky things and in many instances when the auditors come, I will sit here for hours trying to justify certain things that somebody has done, but we don’t even know. Sometimes people pay themselves Daily Sustenance Allowances. We need to be really aware of those things and then use the funds wisely.
Some of the things that we are talking about are simple. What you need is just simple and proper planning. If activities are planned properly, it should be easy to implement them submit all the paperwork.
My advice is that people should avoid keeping the documents of these activities for too long because the tendency is that you might end up losing them. If anyone encounters a problem in retiring the documents, they should consult the Finance Unit. We can guide them on how it is done. Some of the Directorates have been doing this over the years, but there are a few of them who are somehow behind.
*To wrap up Sir, what additional issues do you want to discuss? What advice do you have for both the Government and the donor community?
What I have to say is that the Education Sector has been doing very well to be quite frank especially in terms of the donor intervention and collaboration. All this is due to the leadership that we have in the Ministry starting from the Honourable Minister to the Permanent Secretary. They have created the conducive environment for all of us to do our work to the best of our abilities.
I would also like to extend a hand of appreciation to the donor community for their support to the Education Sector over the years, which has allowed us to register successes that are noted by the whole world. I hope that the other sectors will learn from the successes that we have registered.
There are many sectors in Government and if only one is being referenced internationally, that to me is like a drop in the ocean. Outsiders are learning from us, why not the Government Departments? We are all brothers and sisters and this is a small country.